PublicTechnology’s attempts to find out more about the Counter-Disinformation Unit were rebuffed after a minister was consulted
Credit: Marco Bellucci/CC BY 2.0 Image has been cropped
Despite the sustained efforts of parliamentarians and journalists, the government continues to withhold basic details of its Counter-Disinformation Unit.
The secrecy around its work is maintained on the grounds of a need to protect government’s “relationship with social media platforms”, as well as a desire to “preserve a ‘safe space’ around ministers and government officials”, PublicTechnology can reveal.
The CDU was “stood up” in the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport in March 2020 – with a particular remit to respond to false information about coronavirus circulating on social networks and other websites. According to the government, the unit had previously been activated to monitor online activity related to the European Parliament election and the UK general election that both took place in 2019.
The unit, which brought together resources from the Home Office, Foreign Office, Cabinet Office and the intelligence services, is since understood to have remained in operation and has been responsible for leading government’ response to disinformation – which is defined as the deliberate and malicious dissemination of false or misleading information with the intention to deceive people for political or financial reasons.
The CDU’s remit also includes responding to misinformation, which is considered to be the inadvertent sharing of falsehoods, largely by members of the general public.
Since its creation, very little detail has been made available about the CDU or its work.
There is no public information on the number of staff or funding for the unit, the volume of disinformation being tackled, where this information has been published, any examples of the false narratives being encountered, and very little detail on the subject of misinformation or the steps being taken to remove or counter it.
In the last two years, ministers have responded to 69 written parliamentary questions – from MPs on all sides of the house – enquiring about the work of the CDU.
“There is a strong public interest in preserving a ‘safe space’ around ministers and government officials so that they can communicate with confidence”
DCMS
Three recent examples came from Manchester Central MP Lucy Powell, who asked about the number of pieces of false information that have been “directly rebutted on social media”, the number that have been flagged to each of Twitter, Google, Facebook, and YouTube, and how many staff work at the CDU.
The response from minister for tech and the digital economy Chris Philp indicated that the anti-disinformation function is “still fully operational”.
“The CDU is resourced full time and works in close partnership with cross-government teams,” he said. “In response to the Covid-19 pandemic, the size of the team in DCMS has increased. Requirements are continually reviewed to ensure appropriate levels of resourcing, including surge capacity as needed.”
The minister added: “When false narratives are identified, the CDU coordinates departments across Whitehall to deploy the appropriate response. This can include a direct rebuttal on social media, flagging content to platforms and ensuring public health campaigns are promoted through reliable sources.”
No detail was provided on the volume of information, where it is being published, or how many staff work at the CDU – reinforcing the minister’s previous comments that “as an operational matter, it is not appropriate for the government to give a running commentary on the amount of disinformation identified”.
Philp’s parliamentary responses came as PublicTechnology neared the end of its own six-month quest to find answers to similar questions, or at least a more detailed explanation of why even limited and basic detail has continually been withheld – by an entity whose remit is to point out and combat false and inaccurate information, and promote public bodies as a trusted and reliable source.
Request pending
A Freedom of Information request made to DCMS on 26 July asked whether the CDU was still operational and if its operations were subject to any ongoing periodic review process.
The department’s response indicated that the unit “remains operational and there are no plans for it to be stood down”.
PublicTechnology also asked how many full-time equivalent staff worked at the unit and how many pieces of disinformation it has identified since March 2020. We further requested outline details – subject and platform – of the three most recent instances of information that had been flagged or removed.
5 March 2020
Date on which the CDU was set up to respond
126 working days
Time it took DCMS to adquately respond to PublicTechnology’s FOI request; regulations require a response within 20 working days
69
Number of parliamentary written ministerial answers concerning the work of the CDU
10%
Proportion of global turnover online firms could be fined under proposed online harms laws for failing to remove harmful content; in Facebook’s case this would equate to £8.7bn
Answers to all these questions were ultimately not provided, citing FOI exemptions in cases where “disclosure would, or would be likely to, prejudice the effective conduct of public affairs”.
The department’s response indicated that “in order to apply the [cited] exemption… the department is obliged to receive the ‘reasonable opinion’ of a ‘qualified person’ – in this case a minister of the crown”.
Having sought the opinion of this – unnamed – minister, DCMS laid out, as per its legal duties, the arguments for and against the public interest in releasing the information.
“After careful consideration, we do not feel the public interest is greater than the interest in withholding this information,” it said.
The refusal to provide any detail on the number of staff, the volume of disinformation identified, or even a vague description of the kinds of false narratives being tackled was attributed to the need to maintain good relations with platforms where such material is published. The department also claimed that public detail on the size of CDU’s operations would allow those promoting disinformation to adapt their methods and strategy of doing so.
“In favour of withholding the information we considered that there is a strong public interest in preserving a ‘safe space’ around ministers and government officials so that they can communicate with confidence, including with external third parties,” the response said. “In particular, we consider release of the information would have a negative impact on our relationship with social media platforms. It could risk effective information sharing and data critical to our work. In addition, we consider the release of information would undermine the CDU’s effectiveness by providing insight into the scope and scale of CDU capabilities which could allow malign disinformation actors to tailor their tactics to evade our monitoring capabilities.”
The department did, however, recognise that there are arguments “in favour of releasing the information”.
“We recognise there is a general public interest in government transparency,” it said. “We recognise that greater transparency makes the government more accountable to the electorate and increases trust. We also recognise the current heightened public interest in the issue of disinformation.”
Waiting game
DCMS originally responded to the request in August 2021, indicating that – while it believed it was exempted from releasing the requested information – it needed more time to conduct the necessary tests as to whether “the public interest in maintaining the exemption outweighs the public interest in disclosing the information”.
Having indicated that it aimed to respond by 22 September with details of the public-interest test, no further communication from the department was received until 21 January.
In the meantime, the Information Commissioner’s Office – following a complaint made by PublicTechnology – had also contacted DCMS multiple times in relation to the request.
This included the official notice, sent on 29 November, that the complaint had been upheld and that DCMS must either disclose the information or issue a response that adequately explained the refusal to do so.
“DCMS must take this step within 35 calendar days of the date of this decision notice,” the ICO notice said. “Failure to comply may result in the commissioner making written certification of this fact to the High Court… and may be dealt with as a contempt of court.”
Those 35 days came and went with no response. But a further reminder from the ICO in January did, finally, prompt DCMS to explain its refusal to disclose information.
PublicTechnology intends to contact the department to appeal the refusal – and make the counter-argument.
Mexican Easy Pharm: buying prescription drugs in mexico – Mexican Easy Pharm
reputable mexican pharmacies online https://mexicaneasypharm.shop/# Mexican Easy Pharm
buying prescription drugs in mexico
mexican drugstore online https://mexicaneasypharm.shop/# Mexican Easy Pharm
reputable mexican pharmacies online
http://farmabrufen.com/# BRUFEN prezzo
migliori farmacie online 2024
comprare farmaci online con ricetta https://farmaprodotti.com/# Farmacie on line spedizione gratuita
farmacie online affidabili
Los pagos son rГЎpidos y seguros.: jugabet chile – jugabet.xyz
Gambling can be a social activity here. http://phtaya.tech/# Security measures ensure a safe environment.
Muchos casinos tienen salas de bingo.: jugabet.xyz – jugabet
The poker community is very active here. http://jugabet.xyz/# Los jugadores deben jugar con responsabilidad.
Hay casinos en Santiago y ViГ±a del Mar.: jugabet – jugabet chile
Resorts provide both gaming and relaxation options. https://taya365.art/# Gambling regulations are strictly enforced in casinos.
A variety of gaming options cater to everyone.: phtaya – phtaya casino
The gaming floors are always bustling with excitement. http://jugabet.xyz/# Los jugadores disfrutan del pГіker en lГnea.
High rollers receive exclusive treatment and bonuses.: phtaya login – phtaya casino
A variety of gaming options cater to everyone. https://winchile.pro/# Los jackpots progresivos atraen a los jugadores.
Players often share tips and strategies.: phmacao.life – phmacao
Loyalty programs reward regular customers generously. http://phtaya.tech/# Promotions are advertised through social media channels.
Los jugadores pueden disfrutar desde casa.: win chile – winchile
The gaming floors are always bustling with excitement. http://phmacao.life/# Poker rooms host exciting tournaments regularly.
Live dealer games enhance the casino experience.: phtaya.tech – phtaya casino
Casinos often host special holiday promotions. https://jugabet.xyz/# Los jugadores deben conocer las reglas.
Live music events often accompany gaming nights.: phtaya.tech – phtaya
The Philippines has several world-class integrated resorts. https://phtaya.tech/# Loyalty programs reward regular customers generously.
The casino industry supports local economies significantly.: taya365 com login – taya365 login
The gaming floors are always bustling with excitement. https://taya777.icu/# High rollers receive exclusive treatment and bonuses.
Promotions are advertised through social media channels.: taya365 com login – taya365.art
http://phtaya.tech/# Loyalty programs reward regular customers generously.
Players enjoy a variety of table games.
Slot machines feature various exciting themes.: taya365 com login – taya365.art
The poker community is very active here.: phmacao – phmacao casino
phmacao casino phmacao com Players enjoy both fun and excitement in casinos.
Muchos casinos ofrecen restaurantes y bares.: jugabet.xyz – jugabet chile
Slot tournaments create friendly competitions among players.: taya365 – taya365 com login
http://taya777.icu/# Security measures ensure a safe environment.
The poker community is very active here.
Online gaming is also growing in popularity.: taya365 login – taya365 login
Security measures ensure a safe environment. https://phmacao.life/# The casino industry supports local economies significantly.
Online gaming is also growing in popularity.: taya777.icu – taya777 register login
Casinos often host special holiday promotions.: phmacao casino – phmacao com
Poker rooms host exciting tournaments regularly. http://winchile.pro/# Las apuestas mГnimas son accesibles para todos.
Slot machines feature various exciting themes.: phmacao – phmacao casino
http://taya365.art/# п»їCasinos in the Philippines are highly popular.
Gambling can be a social activity here.
The Philippines has several world-class integrated resorts.: taya777 – taya777.icu
pharmacy no prescription required https://megaindiapharm.shop/# Mega India Pharm
best canadian pharmacy no prescription https://megaindiapharm.com/# top online pharmacy india
xxl mexican pharm: best online pharmacies in mexico – xxl mexican pharm
online pharmacy without prescription https://discountdrugmart.pro/# canadian pharmacy world coupon
pharmacy in canada: easy canadian pharm – easy canadian pharm
canadian pharmacy world coupon https://discountdrugmart.pro/# discount drugs
xxl mexican pharm: buying prescription drugs in mexico – mexico drug stores pharmacies
online pharmacy prescription https://xxlmexicanpharm.com/# reputable mexican pharmacies online
drugmart: discount drug pharmacy – discount drugs
canadian pharmacy discount coupon https://megaindiapharm.com/# india online pharmacy
easy canadian pharm: easy canadian pharm – canadian pharmacy world reviews
mail order prescription drugs from canada http://easycanadianpharm.com/# canadianpharmacyworld
discount drug mart: discount drug mart – discount drug pharmacy
mail order prescription drugs from canada http://xxlmexicanpharm.com/# medicine in mexico pharmacies
Online medicine home delivery Mega India Pharm MegaIndiaPharm
pharmacy discount coupons https://familypharmacy.company/# Online pharmacy USA
Mega India Pharm: top online pharmacy india – Mega India Pharm
cheapest pharmacy for prescriptions http://familypharmacy.company/# cheapest prescription pharmacy
Mega India Pharm: Mega India Pharm – MegaIndiaPharm
canadian pharmacy without prescription https://xxlmexicanpharm.com/# buying prescription drugs in mexico
Best online pharmacy: Best online pharmacy – Cheapest online pharmacy
cheap pharmacy no prescription https://familypharmacy.company/# Cheapest online pharmacy
canada pharmacy not requiring prescription https://xxlmexicanpharm.shop/# xxl mexican pharm
Mega India Pharm: MegaIndiaPharm – MegaIndiaPharm
online pharmacy discount code https://discountdrugmart.pro/# discount drugs
canadian online pharmacy no prescription http://familypharmacy.company/# Best online pharmacy
online pharmacy canada: pharmacy canadian – easy canadian pharm
rx pharmacy no prescription http://easycanadianpharm.com/# easy canadian pharm
online canadian pharmacy coupon https://familypharmacy.company/# Online pharmacy USA
Online pharmacy USA: Cheapest online pharmacy – family pharmacy
legal online pharmacy coupon code https://megaindiapharm.shop/# pharmacy website india
Cheapest online pharmacy: prescription free canadian pharmacy – family pharmacy
canadian pharmacy discount code https://easycanadianpharm.com/# easy canadian pharm
cheapest pharmacy to fill prescriptions without insurance https://discountdrugmart.pro/# drug mart
mail order pharmacy no prescription: Best online pharmacy – Online pharmacy USA
canadian pharmacy coupon https://xxlmexicanpharm.shop/# п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
mexico drug stores pharmacies: reputable mexican pharmacies online – xxl mexican pharm
cheapest prescription pharmacy https://discountdrugmart.pro/# discount drugs
online pharmacy delivery usa: online pharmacy delivery usa – Cheapest online pharmacy
canadian online pharmacy no prescription https://xxlmexicanpharm.com/# mexican mail order pharmacies
Online pharmacy USA: Cheapest online pharmacy – Online pharmacy USA
canada drugs coupon code https://easycanadianpharm.com/# canadian medications
canadian pharmacy no prescription needed: family pharmacy – online pharmacy delivery usa
medicine in mexico pharmacies: п»їbest mexican online pharmacies – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
discount drug mart pharmacy drug mart no prescription required pharmacy
online pharmacy no prescription https://discountdrugmart.pro/# discount drug pharmacy
india pharmacy mail order: MegaIndiaPharm – MegaIndiaPharm
cheapest pharmacy for prescriptions https://xxlmexicanpharm.com/# pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
canadian pharmacy coupon code https://familypharmacy.company/# buying prescription drugs from canada
MegaIndiaPharm: MegaIndiaPharm – MegaIndiaPharm
cheapest pharmacy to fill prescriptions with insurance https://discountdrugmart.pro/# drugmart
easy canadian pharm reputable canadian pharmacy easy canadian pharm
drug mart: online pharmacy prescription – drugmart
buying prescription drugs from canada http://megaindiapharm.com/# india pharmacy mail order
Mega India Pharm: MegaIndiaPharm – MegaIndiaPharm
canadian pharmacy without prescription https://familypharmacy.company/# family pharmacy
Slot dengan bonus putaran gratis sangat populer: bonaslot.site – bonaslot
Permainan slot mudah dipahami dan menyenangkan https://bonaslot.site/# Kasino di Bali menarik banyak pengunjung
Slot menawarkan kesenangan yang mudah diakses: preman69 – preman69 slot
Pemain harus menetapkan batas saat bermain https://preman69.tech/# Slot menawarkan kesenangan yang mudah diakses
Slot dengan tema budaya lokal menarik perhatian https://preman69.tech/# Kasino sering memberikan hadiah untuk pemain setia
Mesin slot menawarkan berbagai tema menarik: preman69.tech – preman69
Kasino memiliki suasana yang energik dan menyenangkan: BonaSlot – BonaSlot
Mesin slot sering diperbarui dengan game baru https://slot88.company/# Slot memberikan kesempatan untuk menang besar
Pemain harus memahami aturan masing-masing mesin: slot demo gratis – slot demo
Kasino memiliki suasana yang energik dan menyenangkan: garuda888.top – garuda888.top
п»їKasino di Indonesia sangat populer di kalangan wisatawan https://preman69.tech/# Slot klasik tetap menjadi favorit banyak orang
Slot menawarkan kesenangan yang mudah diakses https://bonaslot.site/# Slot dengan bonus putaran gratis sangat populer
п»їKasino di Indonesia sangat populer di kalangan wisatawan: bonaslot.site – BonaSlot
Kasino sering mengadakan turnamen slot menarik http://garuda888.top/# Banyak pemain mencari mesin dengan RTP tinggi
Mesin slot dapat dimainkan dalam berbagai bahasa http://bonaslot.site/# Slot dengan tema budaya lokal menarik perhatian
Kasino sering mengadakan turnamen slot menarik: slot88.company – slot88