IT woes caused huge backlog of cases for new government vetting service, report finds
NAO investigation finds that implementation of united IT system created ‘inefficiencies’ of £17m a year
The implementation of a new IT system for vetting government employees created “inefficiencies costing £17m each year”, according to a new report from the National Audit Office.
Auditors also found that staff at United Kingdom Security Vetting (UKSV) – a newly merged vetting provider for civil servants, armed forces specialists, and government contractors – have been forced to resort to manual measures to clear a huge backlog of cases caused by the botched IT rollout and unusable data sets.
The NAO has published the findings of its investigation into UKSV, which was established in 2017 from two separate providers: the Ministry of Defence’s Defence Business Services National Security Vetting; and Foreign and Commonwealth Services National Security Vetting, a trading fund of the Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
The report found that an IT upgrade intended to create a single system to process applications – dubbed the National Security Vetting Solution (NSVS) – had been responsible for a rise in the number of unprocessed cases. It said staff had been forced to re-process failed checks manually and conduct additional assurance checks when some 8,500 files with personal data proved to be digitally unreadable. Added to that, it said that 93% of automated checks involving the police national computer had failed.
- Overambitious transformation plans to cause ‘ugly scrambling for resources’, predicts NAO chief
- Civil service faces pre-Brexit battle with private sector for 'rare' tech skills
- HMRC and Home Office among PAC chair's ‘departments of concern’ over IT project difficulties
A new IT system to replace NSVS is being created and will be implemented in the next 18 months.
“Cabinet Office considers that NSVS is still not meeting requirements in terms of its speed, and is contributing to inefficiencies across government,” the NAO report said. “For example, Cabinet Office recently estimated that NSVS has caused inefficiencies costing £17m each year in relation to recruiting and vetting for government projects. In May 2018, Cabinet Office began developing a replacement system for NSVS, which it plans to be in place by January 2020.”
Overall, the NAO found that that the move to unite the two vetting services had not been supported by an assessment of the expected benefits, costs and risks.
It said that as of July this year the provider still had around 25,600 open cases and did not expect to reach its targets for “developed vetting”, which allows cleared individuals access to more sensitive assets, until December this year. In addition to DV, the provider’s two other most common categories of vetting are counter-terrorist checks and security checks.
According to the NAO, the UKSV had 2017-18 staff costs of £19m, an increase of 17% on the combined staff costs of its predecessor bodies in 2014-15. It said that despite determining that it needed 595 full-time staff, the provider had never had more 507 and was reliant on overtime, agency staff and contracting retired former staff to fill vacant posts.
As the three-year vision of the Government Transformation Strategy moves into its final 12 months, PublicTechnology asked the GDS leader about ministerial changes, departmental siloes,...
We revisit the big news and major events from the second half of 2018
We take a look back at the major developments that shaped the first half of the year
PublicTechnology editor Sam Trendall picks out the topics and trends that will dominate the year ahead, and revisits the predictions of a year ago to see any of them came to pass
BT shows how to plan and manage your network to unlock the rewards of the cloud
Whether you need mobile devices or fibre optics, cloud services or switchboard systems, with UniCORN you'll have more purchasing power and unlock benefits you wouldn't get alone
BT understand the public sector in the capital. Frameworks offer a single, simplified way to get the ICT products and services you need
Download Gartner's expert analysis to help you plan your SD-WAN implementation