Government’s commercial head Gareth Rhys Williams has claimed that a previous PAC report criticising direct awards does not ‘fairly represent the actual position’ – but the committee chair has hit back
Government’s chief commercial officer has pushed back at claims that money is being wasted because a large number of public contracts are not awarded through competitive tenders.
Insufficient competition was among a number of issues with public procurement identified in a Public Accounts Committee report last year that said government could not demonstrate value for money across billions of pounds of spending. More effective use of competition could save the public purse between £4bn and £7.7bn, the MPs said.
The report found that “around a third of the total contract value of more than £100bn awarded by major departments during 2021-22 were not subject to competition”.
But in a letter to PAC chair Dame Meg Hillier, government CCO Gareth Rhys Williams said he did not believe the estimate “fairly represents the actual position”.
He said it was a “misunderstanding” that may stem from a National Audit Office report that showed two-thirds of the £100bn worth of contracts awarded by major departments 2021-22 were subject to competition in some form.
“It is not the case that a third of major contracts awarded by major departments during 2021-22 were not subject to competition, and the actual figure is a lot lower,” Rhys Williams said.
The NAO report in question showed that when looking at the monetary value of contracts awarded that year, 34% of the £100bn figure was spent through contract extensions and just 5% was through uncompetitive direct awards.
However, when looking at the number of contracts, contract extensions accounted for just 13%, while 24% were direct awards.
“Aside from a small proportion – less than 5% – originating from direct awards, all of these contracts would have been competed at the point of initial tender. And many of them will have had commercial provisions which allow for safeguards and protections for taxpayers, for instance; pre-agreed prices for the extension period, or retaining the option to renegotiate or to re-compete on the open market,” Rhys Williams said.
Related content
- ‘A complete lack of control’ – how Horizon highlights the public sector’s over-reliance on outsourcers
- CCS defends Digital Marketplace closure and pledges to ‘reinstate transparency’
- Suppliers urged to call out departments flouting new procurement guidelines
“I worry therefore that the implication of extending a competed contract is always poor commercial practice; in fact it can offer real value for money. I would be as concerned as you would be if indeed we were not competing such a large volume of work; unfortunately that is the impression left with the reader of the release, and has been picked up by the press.”
While the NAO report did not suggest contract extensions were never appropriate, it did say they “may indicate missed opportunities for competition” and noted that there were “many cases of departments choosing non-compliant extension of contracts, rather than the competitive procurement process, which should be the default”.
It also said: “Government procurement guidance states that where departments have been forced into extensions through failing to plan early enough, this is a very weak position.”
In a response to Rhys Williams, Hillier said she was “encouraged” by the progress described in his letter, including the training and efforts to plug data gaps, but did not agree that there was a problem with the committee’s interpretation that “around a third of the total contract value of more than £100bn awarded by major departments during 2021-22 were not subject to competition”.
“I am satisfied that this was a reasonable inference based on the information available,” Hillier wrote.
She cited the NAO report’s finding that “63% were competed to some extent, comprising 61% of the total value”, and added that both the NAO and PAC reports had been “generous in assuming that in all cases calling contracts off of a framework counts as competition”.
Data gaps
Both the NAO and PAC reports raised concerns about gaps in procurement data. “Government has not been fully capturing data on procurement, much less using the analytics from the collected data to draw insights on how competition in public procurement is operating within government and give context to purchasing decisions,” the PAC report said.
It said “significant issues with the quality and completeness of data on contracts” were making it harder to solve procurement issues, capitalise on value-for-money benefits and evaluate the functioning of competitive, innovative, and open markets.
In his letter, Rhys Williams said “we are the first to concede that our data is incomplete, particularly outside of central government”.
“However, the press release fails to mention that the GCF does not currently have the regulatory rights to obtain much of the information that we all agree that we need, and consequently doesn’t have the mechanism with which to collect, store and process it,” he said.
He said the Procurement Act, which recently received royal assent, would help to “plug this gap” as it requires that contracting authorities publish that information.
“I am keen to avoid the perception by the committee or the public that this analysis is currently unavailable through lack of effort or will,” he added.
“I absolutely share your zeal for enhanced public sector efficiency and value for money. The implementation of the new Procurement Act offers us a huge opportunity to transform public procurement, and now it has received Royal Assent we have an implementation plan, with milestones, in place,” he said.
“I’m pleased to say that 8,000 colleagues have already looked at the first set of the training material, and we are making good progress at briefing industry groups.”
The PAC report raised concerns about the way in which framework agreements are used, saying the government commercial function has not provided sufficient guidance to address the potential risks to competitive benefits of these agreements. In particular, the MPs warned that “inappropriate use of frameworks may lead to limiting competition either by not having enough suppliers for a mini competition or too many suppliers to effectively award a contract”.
In her letter to Rhys Williams, Hiller reiterated the committee’s finding that the use of frameworks has soared from 20% of contracts by value in 2018-19 to 68% in 2021-22.
“I note the information in your letter about the figure for ‘non-competed’ contracts including contract extensions. This was not addressed in my committee’s report,” she added.
“However, had it done so we may have pointed to the worryingly high volume of these extensions and the weakness that suggests.”
Hillier said she looked forward to receiving a more detailed response to the committee’s proposals through the Treasury minute process.
벼룩시장 신문그대로보기 (구인구직, 부동산) 벼룩시장 신문그대로보기 바로가기 그리고 지역별 벼룩시장 종이신문그대로보기 방법 (구인구직, 부동산) 알아볼게요. 교차로신문 같이 벼룩시장은 지역별 일자리, 구인구직, 부동산 등 다양한 정보를 제공해요. 교차로신문그대로보기 바로가기는 아래에서 확인하고, 오늘은 벼룩시장 신문그대로보기 바로가기 그리고 사용법 섹스카지노사이트
대전호박나이트
전신스타킹
안성출장마사지
청도페이스라인출장
https://klero.tistory.com/tag/설날20고속도로20통행료20무료20기간
울산콜걸
청도페이스라인출장
영등포안마살롱
https://pornmaster.fun/hd/indian-xxx-mystery
https://pornmaster.fun/hd/hansika-tinman-xossip-xxx-com-pu
https://pornmaster.fun/hd/kat-chuamage-xxx
Transform Your Look with Bragle’s Elegant Sweaters – Experience unparalleled sophistication with Bragle’s luxury sweaters—the perfect fusion of warmth and sophistication. Designed from luxurious fabrics like cashmere and merino wool, each design highlights timeless class for those with a preference for upscale clothing. From timeless classics to contemporary elegance, Bragle sweaters effortlessly adapt from work to evening, keeping you cozy and flawlessly fashionable. Explore **Bragle.com** to explore the full range and embrace the ultimate in luxury.
https://pornmaster.fun/hd/快三登录注册(关于快三登录注册的简介)-【网hk589点org】-旧版够力七星彩正版牛爷资料(关于旧版够力七星彩正版牛爷资料的简介)cukncukn-【网hk589E38082org】-亿博体育平台app下载(关于亿博体育平台app下载的简介)nzhk6zxb-lxs
https://pws1999.tistory.com/150
https://mrdeeply.tistory.com/518
이태원스웨디시안마게이클럽
대전나이트클럽
전신스타킹
https://itlearn.kr/
Transform Your Look with Bragle’s Elegant Sweaters – Uncover unparalleled sophistication with Bragle’s women’s sweaters—the ideal combination of coziness and style. Made from premium materials like soft merino wool and cashmere, each piece highlights refined elegance for those with a penchant for high-end fashion. From timeless classics to contemporary elegance, Bragle sweaters effortlessly adapt from day to night, keeping you cozy and flawlessly fashionable. Explore **Bragle.com** to shop the full range and experience the ultimate in luxury.
벼룩시장 구인구직 및 신문 그대로 보기 (PC/모바일) | 구인구직 앱 어플 무료 설치 다운로드 | 모바일 벼룩시장 보는 방법 | 벼룩시장 부동산 | 지역별 벼룩시장 | 벼룩시장 종이신문 에 대해 알아보겠습니다. 섹스카지노사이트
벼룩시장 구인구직 및 신문 그대로 보기 (PC/모바일) | 구인구직 앱 어플 무료 설치 다운로드 | 모바일 벼룩시장 보는 방법 | 벼룩시장 부동산 | 지역별 벼룩시장 | 벼룩시장 종이신문 에 대해 알아보겠습니다. 섹스카지노사이트
벼룩시장 구인구직 및 신문 그대로 보기 (PC/모바일) | 구인구직 앱 어플 무료 설치 다운로드 | 모바일 벼룩시장 보는 방법 | 벼룩시장 부동산 | 지역별 벼룩시장 | 벼룩시장 종이신문 에 대해 알아보겠습니다. 섹스카지노사이트
대전세븐나이트
전신스타킹
청도페이스라인출장
전신스타킹
이태원스웨디시안마게이클럽
영등포안마살롱
대전호박나이트
하동동해출장만남 소자본 창업
수원출장샵
https://itlearn.kr
https//pornmaster.fun/hd/pov-tiktok
https://itgunza.com/180
https://itgunza.com/187
https://itgunza.com/355
https://honeytiplabs.com/갤럭시-화면-자동-꺼짐/
https://ajaedotcom.tistory.com/entry/벼룩시장-전국-사용-방법
울산콜걸
https://ddnews.co.kr/blog/2023/03/19/mbti-meaning/
이태원게이바
여행지
https://nicesongtoyou.com/loan/small-loans/
영등포안마살롱
https://nicesongtoyou.com/welfare/seniorjobs/
강남안마시술소중계업체
https://fifaworldcup.modoo.at/
https://news.gorgopage.com/255
대전호박나이트
강남안마시술소중계업체
대전호박나이트
https://sportscom.co.kr/short-term-delinquent-interest/
https://chotiple.tistory.com/tag/탑텐20블랙프라이데이20행사
https://chotiple.tistory.com/tag/비말마스크구입처
https://nicesongtoyou.com/welfare/
https://dnolife.net/software/samsungdex/
https://nicesongtoyou.com/tax/corporate-tax/
https://dnolife.net/software/bluestacks10/
https://itmoney4you.com/mbc-온에어/
https://itmoney4you.com/mbc-온에어/
https://dday.tistory.com/751
Wonderful website you have here but I was curious about if you knew of any user discussion forums that cover the same topics discussed here? I’d really love to be a part of community where I can get advice from other knowledgeable people that share the same interest. If you have any recommendations, please let me know. Bless you!
https://madreviewer.tistory.com/entry/EC9DB8EC8AA4ED8380-EAB880EC94A8ECB2B4-EBB094EABEB8EAB8B0-ED81B4EBA6AD-ED959CEBB288EC9DB4EBA9B4-EB819D
https://new-software.download/windows/kakaostory/
Greetings from Idaho! I’m bored at work so I decided to browse your site on my iphone during lunch break. I enjoy the info you provide here and can’t wait to take a look when I get home. I’m surprised at how fast your blog loaded on my mobile .. I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyways, good blog!
My brother recommended I might like this blog. He was entirely right. This post actually made my day. You can not imagine simply how much time I had spent for this info! Thanks!
https://new-software.download/windows/hoax-eliminator/
glad to be one of the visitors on this amazing web site : D.
https://bestkkultip.tistory.com/16
https://itgunza.com/3457
https://blog.naver.com/combine8589/223743339311