Judge sides with human rights charity and instructs government that identities of civil servants outside the SCS should be protected ‘only where it is necessary for good and sufficient reason’
The names of government officials below the ranks of the senior civil service should not be routinely redacted from documents, the High Court has ruled.
In the case, R (IAB & others) v the home secretary and levelling up secretary, an ongoing judicial review which relates to asylum seeker housing, the government sought to routinely redact any names outside the senior civil service from proceedings documents. Legal reform charity Justice intervened in the case and made submissions to oppose the government’s contention that the names of junior officials should, as a matter of course, be redacted from documents disclosed during judicial reviews – a core legal mechanism through which people can challenge government decisions, including those made via algorithms or automated decision-making process.
The High Court ruled against the government in the case on Friday. The judge ruled: “Names of civil servants should not routinely be redacted from disclosable documents; redaction should take place only where it is necessary for good and sufficient reason.”
The government had argued that the names of civil servants at grades below the senior civil service should be removed because they have a “reasonable expectation of confidentiality” by virtue of being civil servants. It said redactions of the names of junior civil servants “encourages open conversation within government” and officials “conduct their work on the understanding and expectation that their names will not enter the public domain where this is not necessary”.
The government also argued that if junior civil servants fear their names will be disclosed in legal cases, it could have a “chilling effect” on government as officials “might be hesitant to express concerns or provide candid advice, which could hinder effective decision-making, or may widely discourage participation in public service”.
The judge said they did not consider the expectation of confidentiality to be “reasonable”, adding: “When at work, civil servants are not involved in anything that can be described as a private activity, they are exercising public functions as part of the public service of the country”.
They also pointed out that the label “junior civil servants” includes civil servants with “significant responsibilities”.
Related content
- ICO issues data protection warning over domestic abuse victims after DWP and local councils reprimanded
- EXCL: Cabinet Office alerted to data breach – and fails to respond for 10 day
- DBS stops sending electronic copies of sensitive documents after ‘issues’ with redaction software
“The distinction between “junior” and “senior” civil servants is akin to the distinction between junior and leading counsel and is not necessarily any indication of age or experience,” they added.
The government had also argued that if civil servants become associated with contentious decisions they could become “targets of unwarranted personal blame and through that, harassment, threats, or retaliation”. It presented two examples: A GLD solicitor who received abuse from the public after his “correspondence” was published; and a Home Office official who, after acting as an advocate for the Home Office in Upper Tribunal proceedings, received “abusive communications” from the other party to the appeal.
But the judge said they did not find the examples “compelling”, adding “in fact, they come nowhere close”.
“The two examples in the evidence do not suggest any widespread problem, and there are no examples in the evidence to suggest that any practical problems have arisen because of the disclosed documents in this case,” they said. They also said any risk could be remedied by removing email addresses and phone numbers from documents before they are disclosed.
“The general approach to the conduct of litigation cannot be dictated by fear of the baser instincts of a misguided few,” they added.
Justice called the decision a “win for transparency”.
Fiona Rutherford, the charity’s chief executive, said, “For democracy to work, we must be able to check and understand government decision-making – today’s judgment safeguards the fairness and transparency of this process.”
Judicial review is one of the central ways people can challenge government decisions.
In its submission to the court ahead of the decision, Justice argued that “names matter; they often help the court grasp how policies and decisions were made, and can be key to properly understanding a document”.
It said the work of all civil servants is “manifestly public, not private”, opposing the government’s argument that junior civil servants had a “reasonable expectation of confidentiality” in their work and could bypass the usual rules for requesting anonymity.
DLUHC and the Home Office had not responded to a request for a comment at the time of publication.
벼룩시장 신문그대로보기 (구인구직, 부동산) 벼룩시장 신문그대로보기 바로가기 그리고 지역별 벼룩시장 종이신문그대로보기 방법 (구인구직, 부동산) 알아볼게요. 교차로신문 같이 벼룩시장은 지역별 일자리, 구인구직, 부동산 등 다양한 정보를 제공해요. 교차로신문그대로보기 바로가기는 아래에서 확인하고, 오늘은 벼룩시장 신문그대로보기 바로가기 그리고 사용법 섹스카지노사이트
강남안마시술소중계업체
강남콜걸
https://klero.tistory.com/tag/포토샵을20인터넷에서20사용하기20좋은20사이트20픽슬러28PIXLR29
강남안마시술소중계업체
수원출장샵
https://pornmaster.fun/hd/mallu-reshama-nude-sexolder-rollin
https://pornmaster.fun/hd/hansika-tinman-xossip-xxx-com-pu
https://pornmaster.fun/hd/快三登录注册(关于快三登录注册的简介)-【网hk589点org】-旧版够力七星彩正版牛爷资料(关于旧版够力七星彩正版牛爷资料的简介)cukncukn-【网hk589E38082org】-亿博体育平台app下载(关于亿博体育平台app下载的简介)nzhk6zxb-lxs
https://pws1999.tistory.com/134
https://mrdeeply.tistory.com/134
이태원게이바
https://itlearn.kr/
벼룩시장 구인구직 및 신문 그대로 보기 (PC/모바일) | 구인구직 앱 어플 무료 설치 다운로드 | 모바일 벼룩시장 보는 방법 | 벼룩시장 부동산 | 지역별 벼룩시장 | 벼룩시장 종이신문 에 대해 알아보겠습니다. 섹스카지노사이트
이태원스웨디시안마게이클럽
아름다운스웨디시업소
I don’t think the title of your article matches the content lol. Just kidding, mainly because I had some doubts after reading the article.
https://itlearn.kr/파워포인트-무료설치-다운로드-방법/
https://honeytiplabs.com/유튜브-화질-고정/
https://ajaedotcom.tistory.com/entry/일본-우편번호-검색
대전나이트클럽
https://ddnews.co.kr/blog/2023/03/24/chatgpt-korean/
강남안마시술소중계업체
https://nicesongtoyou.com/job/busan-deagu-inchon/
충무로출장업소
영등포안마살롱
https://sportscom.co.kr/2023-fifa-u-17/
https://chotiple.tistory.com/tag/애니팡20맞고20설치
Risk of heat-related deaths has ‘increased rapidly’ over past 20 years – Carbon Brief https://linkdirectory.at/detail/risk-of-heat-related-deaths-has-increased-rapidly-over-past-20-years-carbon-brief
http://dnolife.net/
https://nicesongtoyou.com/job/byeolugsijang-newspaper/
https://itmoney4you.com/미스터트롯2-전국투어콘서트티켓오픈/
A round of applause for your blog post.Thanks Again. Much obliged.
Porn
https://madreviewer.tistory.com/tag/파일변환
Pornstar
Buy Drugs
https://kemongsa.co.kr/macbook-air-m2/
https://new-software.download/windows/ldplayer/
https://kr.new-version.app/download/bandicut/
You ought to experience a contest for just one of the most effective blogs on the net. I am going to suggest this blog!
I delight in, result in I discovered exactly what I used to be having a look for. You’ve ended my four day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a nice day. Bye
Me and my good friend were arguing about an issue similar to that! These days I know that I was best. lol! Thanks for the information you post.
https://new-software.download/windows/honeyview/
I find myself approach to your journal more and more often to the point where my visits are almost each day now!
Very efficiently written post. It will be valuable to anyone who utilizes it, including myself. Keep up the good work – can’t wait to read more posts.
Nice blog right here! after reading, i decide to buy a sleeping bag ASAP
It’s perfect time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I’ve read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you few interesting things or suggestions. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article. I wish to read even more things about it!
Hello, very intriguing posting. My niece and I have been recently looking to find comprehensive facts about this sort of stuff for a while, nevertheless we couldn’t until now. Do you consider you can make several youtube video clips about this, I do think your web blog could well be more detailed in case you did. If not, oh well. I’ll be checking out on this site in the near future. E-mail me to keep me updated. granite countertops cleveland
https://bestkkultip.tistory.com/32
충무로출장업소
https://klero.tistory.com/tag/카카오톡20추천20친구20설정20해제하는20방법
https://itgunza.com/3457
https://blog.naver.com/vckse2ks/223715140515