Cabinet Office minister Lord Agnew says overuse of external experts has ‘infantilised’ officials
Credit: Pixabay
The civil service’s reliance on consultants has “infantilised” officials and is stopping them from being able to work on the most challenging issues in government, Cabinet Office minister Lord Theodore Agnew has said.
In a letter to the Alex Chisholm, the chief operating officer of the civil service, and Gareth Rhys Williams, chief commercial officer, Agnew said a reliance on external consultants is “providing poor value for money”, but also “infantilises the civil service by depriving our brightest people of opportunities to work on some of the most challenging, fulfilling and crunchy issues”.
In the letter, seen by the Guardian, he said the government seemed to be ineffectual using graduate Fast Stream civil servants to carry out work that is outsourced to consultants, “using similar people at a vastly inflated cost”.
“This is unacceptable,” the letter stated.
Related content
- Shadow minister claims government ‘addicted’ to outsourcing
- Whitehall slammed for ‘secretive’ Brexit consultancy spending
- Consultancies swipe another £160m of government Brexit-prep contracts
He said the Cabinet Office would be reviewing the cost controls on consultancy spending “to provide minsters with confidence that departments are beating down on unnecessary spending and instead look to build internal capacity”.
He said data would also need to be improved to do this, and that Cabinet Office officials would be “engaging [Chisholm] in work to develop clear, consistent coding systems so that in the future we can assure ourselves that consultancy and professional spending is not misleading or classified under categories that are not subject to Cabinet Office spend control approval”.
The letter acknowledged that that spending on consultants has risen in part because the UK is leaving the EU. It was reported last year that government spending on consultants and temporary staff rose by nearly 20% to hit £1.8bn, as departments drafted in outside help for Brexit preparations and IT projects.
Agnew criticised the extent of external help the civil service has used to prepare for EU exit.
“Four years after voting to leave the European Union it is unacceptable that the civil service still has not developed the capability to deliver this through our own civil servants,” he wrote.
He said departments should name a lead official “to work with teams in the Cabinet Office and the Treasury to develop and implement proposals to address these issues”. The letter, sent on 15 September, called for these proposals to be submitted by October.
Commenting on Agnew’s letter, Dave Penman, the head of the FDA union for senior civil servants, told the Guardian that “consultant spending is one of many tools that will have been used to respond to the demands from ministers and can only be looked at in the context of the environment faced at that time”.
He added: “Ministers need to understand the challenges that have been placed on the civil service if they seriously want to make rational reform, rather than lecturing departments for taking the measures that were necessary to deliver a previous government’s priorities.”
A government spokesperson told the paper: “Since 2010, the government has taken considerable steps to reduce unnecessary spending and protect taxpayers’ money. Ministers are concerned that government is too reliant on consultants and have written to departments to make clear that services should only be procured when external expertise is essential and represents value for money. We want to harness the wide range of skills within the civil service.”
Unlock the 2025 Tax Guide for LLCs and S Corps
Dear,
Are you ready to optimize your taxes in 2025?
We’re excited to share the 2025 Edition of The Taxpayer’s Comprehensive Guide to LLCs and S Corps by WCG CPAs and Jason Watson,
CPA—a must-have resource for business owners and tax-savvy individuals.
What’s Inside
With over 400 pages of updated insights, this guide covers:
New Limits: IRA, 401(k), and Social Security updates for 2025.
Advanced Strategies: Multi-entity setups and shareholder salary optimization.
Business Essentials: Tips on deal structures, liability protection, and operating agreements.
Learn How to:
Cut self-employment taxes with S Corps.
Navigate state taxes, Nexus rules, and Section 199A deductions.
Maximize retirement planning and more!
Don’t miss this opportunity to stay ahead of the curve and make the most of your tax strategies in 2025.
Get Your Guide Now @ https://bit.ly/3PwRAzd
Best regards,
Unlock the 2025 Tax Guide for LLCs and S Corps
Dear,
Are you ready to optimize your taxes in 2025?
We’re excited to share the 2025 Edition of The Taxpayer’s Comprehensive Guide to LLCs and S Corps by WCG CPAs and Jason Watson,
CPA—a must-have resource for business owners and tax-savvy individuals.
What’s Inside
With over 400 pages of updated insights, this guide covers:
New Limits: IRA, 401(k), and Social Security updates for 2025.
Advanced Strategies: Multi-entity setups and shareholder salary optimization.
Business Essentials: Tips on deal structures, liability protection, and operating agreements.
Learn How to:
Cut self-employment taxes with S Corps.
Navigate state taxes, Nexus rules, and Section 199A deductions.
Maximize retirement planning and more!
Don’t miss this opportunity to stay ahead of the curve and make the most of your tax strategies in 2025.
Get Your Guide Now @ https://bit.ly/3PwRAzd
Best regards,
Unlock the 2025 Tax Guide for LLCs and S Corps
Dear,
Are you ready to optimize your taxes in 2025?
We’re excited to share the 2025 Edition of The Taxpayer’s Comprehensive Guide to LLCs and S Corps by WCG CPAs and Jason Watson,
CPA—a must-have resource for business owners and tax-savvy individuals.
What’s Inside
With over 400 pages of updated insights, this guide covers:
New Limits: IRA, 401(k), and Social Security updates for 2025.
Advanced Strategies: Multi-entity setups and shareholder salary optimization.
Business Essentials: Tips on deal structures, liability protection, and operating agreements.
Learn How to:
Cut self-employment taxes with S Corps.
Navigate state taxes, Nexus rules, and Section 199A deductions.
Maximize retirement planning and more!
Don’t miss this opportunity to stay ahead of the curve and make the most of your tax strategies in 2025.
Get Your Guide Now @ https://bit.ly/3PwRAzd
Best regards,
Hi,
Upgrade your business connections with stunning digital business cards!
With a simple scan of a Popl QR code, you can instantly share your fully up-to-date contact info,
This makes it easy for other businesses or clients to save you as a contact directly on their phones.
It’s a fast, modern way to network and ensure your details are always current.
Say goodbye to outdated paper cards!
Would you be ready to make networking easier?
Learn more @ https://popl.pxf.io/XYQZMg
Best regards,
Hi,
Upgrade your business connections with stunning digital business cards!
With a simple scan of a Popl QR code, you can instantly share your fully up-to-date contact info,
This makes it easy for other businesses or clients to save you as a contact directly on their phones.
It’s a fast, modern way to network and ensure your details are always current.
Say goodbye to outdated paper cards!
Would you be ready to make networking easier?
Learn more @ https://popl.pxf.io/XYQZMg
Best regards,
Hi,
Upgrade your business connections with stunning digital business cards!
With a simple scan of a Popl QR code, you can instantly share your fully up-to-date contact info,
This makes it easy for other businesses or clients to save you as a contact directly on their phones.
It’s a fast, modern way to network and ensure your details are always current.
Say goodbye to outdated paper cards!
Would you be ready to make networking easier?
Learn more @ https://popl.pxf.io/XYQZMg
Best regards,