Whitehall suffers from ‘a culture of denial when a project is going badly’, says PAC chair Hillier
The head of the Public Accounts Committee has lamented a lack of transparency and information sharing across the civil service
Credit: Peter/Flickr/CC BY-SA 2.0
Civil servants must be more open about the progress of projects happening within their departments, the head of the Public Accounts Committee has said.
Writing for PublicTechnology sister publication The House, Meg Hillier said there was too little accountability for projects and spending within government as departments were too reticent to share updates on how projects were progressing.
“Despite the Freedom of Information Act, the default is too often not to share information,” Hillier said.
This had become apparent when her committee was examining confidential papers about suppliers of government services, she said. "When we eventually saw them, we were struck by how much of the information was already in the public domain. Government must be more open about its dealings with contractors who are receiving vast sums of taxpayers’ money."
- Government transformation projects ‘promise too much at the outset’ – IPA chief
- HMRC and Home Office among PAC chair's ‘departments of concern’ over IT project difficulties
- Cabinet Office ‘lacks leverage’ to ensure procurement best practice – PAC
This lack of transparency is exacerbated by civil servants’ unwillingness to share the unvarnished truth with MPs, she said. “The committee gives some credit to civil servants who tell us candidly about the risks in a project. But, behind the scenes, it can be unpopular in Whitehall to come and tell it, warts and all, at committee. Too often, optimism can override common sense.”
Hillier said there was often a “culture of denial when a project is going badly”, pointing to the Emergency Services Network, a new communication system that has been subject to huge delays, as an example of where greater transparency could improve delivery.
In an effort to increase accountability, the Labour MP for Hackney South and Shoreditch said her committee would ask civil servants to give evidence on projects for which they had been responsible, “no matter where they have moved on to”. At the moment, it is difficult to hold ministers or civil servants to account when they have moved on to other briefs by the time their projects come under scrutiny, Hillier said.
“We are also keen to see project delivery skills more highly valued in the civil service promotion ladder,” she added.
One of the greatest challenges departments face is Brexit, which Hillier said has “skewed the work of all departments and led them to reprioritise work and, in some cases, delay other projects”. She repeated her committee’s call in May for greater transparency and clarity about what Brexit would mean in practice.
Hillier said at the time that departments faced “extreme pressure” to deliver their Brexit preparations. “If parliament is to hold them to account then it is vital that government is as transparent as possible on the progress being made,” she said.
PublicTechnology talks to the minister for implementation about the challenges and successes of an eventful year for the Government Digital Service, and where the organisation goes from...
At GovTech Summit in Paris, Justin Trudeau speaks of need for government to ensure technology provides a ‘positive alternative’
A House of Commons inquiry into the work of GDS to data and the state of digital government has begun publishing its findings. PublicTechnology looks at what a range of experts have had...
Department commences search for replacement for Mayank Prakash and confirms Simon McKinnon as interim tech chief
There’s a vast network that keeps our internet running, and it lives under the ocean
BT thinks The Internet of Things is about to undergo a revolution. Over the past two decades, we've seen IoT tech evolve from a possibility, to a novelty, to an established tool that plays a vital...
Quantum computers will soon make some of our strongest encryption useless. And that's where quantum cryptography comes in
BT knows that digital security isn't just about technology. It's about the partnerships, intelligence and expertise you need to stay one step ahead in the security race.