Whitehall oversight risks stifling local service reforms, warns think tank

Written by Jim Dunton on 2 August 2016 in News

Fear of being penalised for failings with local service redesigns is stopping councils from fully sharing their experiences with peer organisations, according to a new study by the Institute for Government.

Researchers at the think tank investigated how local authorities exchanged insight on their service integration work with peer organisations and found that in some cases concerns over being judged harshly by central government departments and regulators contributed to a reluctance to acknowledge mistakes that others could learn from.

The study looked at examples of integration in social care, health, and welfare - all of which have a strong IT component - and found that barriers to openly sharing details of failures as well as successes risked a repetition of past mistakes that could stall government plans to rein in public spending. 

The report authors said interviews with practitioners found that local areas were particularly keen to hear “messy” evidence about pitfalls that authorities had  encountered that could be learned from, but that such information was often hidden. 

Related content

Health and social care integration about leadership as well as tech, say local government and NHS bodies

Local Government Association names digital-transformation funding winners 

“Interviewees explained that they can be reluctant to share progress, challenges and frustrations in forums convened by central government, regulators or national arm’s-length bodies, because of concerns that the information could be used to assess and sanction performance,“ they said.

“This is particularly the case when it is unclear whether a national or central government team is playing an assurance or support function.

“We heard that one particular learning scheme had low take-up because local areas were anxious that any information shared could be used to criticise performance, even though reassurance that this would not occur was provided at the outset.”

The report, Public Service Reform: Supporting learning to integrate services and improve outcomes, said it was vital that government departments and regulators encouraged peer-led learning models that delivered real-time insight on challenges and setbacks faced by practitioners.

It said such a result would be best achieved through face-to-face learning opportunities that were peer or sector-led.

The report added that central government should use the resulting insights to make changes to national policy and regulatory, legislative and funding frameworks that currently hinder local public service integration. 

IfG programme director Dr Jo Casebourne said that at a time when capacity in local government was declining it was ever more important to ensure that useful information on service redesign was shared between local authorities.

“Better collaboration between local organisations is crucial to improving public services,“ she said.

“But those on the ground still don’t have the support they need. 

“Particularly with money and resources so stretched, the government must invest properly and only fund programmes that we know actually work.”

Share this page




Please login to post a comment or register for a free account.

Related Articles

Interview: CDDO chief Lee Devlin on the ‘move from being disruptive to collaborative’
23 May 2023

In the first of a series of exclusive interviews, the head of government’s ‘Digital HQ’ talks to PublicTechnology about the Central Digital and Data Office’s work to unlock £8bn...

Digital Leaders’ Download: Ex-HMPPS leader Farrar on how technology was crucial in helping prisons’ pandemic response
31 May 2023

In the first of a series of interviews with government’s biggest figures, PublicTechnology and CDDO caught up with  Jo Farrar to discuss exploring virtual reality and AI, and why it’...

Consultation reveals widespread opposition to proposed data-sharing laws for government login system
26 May 2023

Overwhelming majority of respondents voice disapproval but government will press on with plans to bring forward legislation

Digital minister: ‘It’s important to the government that the British public has confidence in how we use their data’
23 May 2023

In a piece written for PublicTechnology, parliamentary secretary Alex Burghart discusses progress with One Login and the significance of legislative changes

Related Sponsored Articles

Proactive defence: A new take on cyber security
16 May 2023

The traditional reactive approach to cybersecurity, which involves responding to attacks after they have occurred, is no longer sufficient. Murielle Gonzalez reports on a webinar looking at...