Commission calls for app for citizens to track government money – and no more spending reviews

Written by Jim Dunton on 13 April 2021 in News

Paper urges overhaul of financial planning system

A commission set up to drive reform across Whitehall has dismissed HM Treasury’s Spending Review process as a “political scrap over who gets the biggest budget” and called for a complete overhaul of the way government manages its money.

The Commission for Smart Government has also called for a website and mobile app through which citizens could track how money is being spent and how government is performing.

The commission, which is chaired by former Conservative minister Lord Nick Herbert, said that as ministers looked to spend £3 trillion over the next three years, departments needed their funding to be guided by a proper planning process that focused money where it is most needed.

In a new discussion paper on finance, the commission says that while the UK has previously led the way in financial planning and whole-of-government accounting, the default position is not to give enough thought to trade-offs between spending on different parts of the system – or long-term planning.

Related content

The commission said the new arrangements should be underpinned by an “excellent financial planning IT system” that was run by “expert, high-powered staff at the centre of government”. The discussion paper said there should also be “full transparency of plans and performance” available through the creation of a user-friendly web portal so taxpayers could find out how the government is spending their money via a smartphone app.

The paper, overseen by former government lead non-executive director Sir Ian Cheshire, says “serious real-world consequences” have followed from a “weak understanding of the relationship between funding and operational performance” in recent years.

It points to “unrealistically low” plans for spending on public services such as social care and prisons in the 2015 Spending Review, which led to a cycle of “service and political crises and emergency cash injections”.  

The commission said the Spending Review system should be replaced with a new “best-in-class system of financial planning” that worked across government to establish how money could be spent to realise the government’s stated intentions.

Part of the process would involve the creation of a common rating system to decide whether departments and other public bodies were good at financial management, or whether they needed help to improve.

Cheshire said the panel – which includes former Department for International Development perm sec Sir Suma Chakrabarti, ex-civil service reform adviser Baroness Simone Finn, and former No.10 policy unit head Baroness Camilla Cavendish –  was acutely aware of the centrality of finance to its work.

“It is not so much a case that money makes the world go round, as money turns the government’s aspirations into results, if it is managed well,” he said. “Succeeding as a government, and persuading the public that their money isn’t being wasted, depends on excellent financial management. With the public finances under intense pressure for the foreseeable future, government needs to make the maximum impact from every penny spent.”


Share this page




Please login to post a comment or register for a free account.

Related Articles

PublicTechnology research: five things we learned about the future of digital government
22 April 2021

A recent study finds that the pandemic has boosted budgets – but legacy tech remains a big barrier to progress

Innovate UK nabs tech exec Mukerjee as new chief
7 May 2021

Former insurance and electronics bigwig becomes innovation agency's first permanent head in three years

A closer look: what now for the government’s vaccine passport plans?
29 April 2021

PublicTechnology examines the government’s strategy for offering a digital certification tool, and its key advantages and challenges

Related Sponsored Articles

Tackling vaccination misinformation with local government communications
9 March 2021

As misinformation about the coronavirus vaccine spreads, Granicus outlines key considerations for local government when delivering a successful vaccine communications campaign 

Avoid Infrastructure Paralysis: Six benefits of moving legacy Oracle workloads to the cloud
6 April 2021

There are many reasons to keep your Oracle workloads running on local servers. But there are even more reasons to move them to the cloud as part of a wider digital transition strategy. Six Degrees...

How are Government employees responding to the challenge of multi-agency collaboration in 2021?
10 March 2021

Seven years after the Home Office shared findings from its 'Multi-Agency Working and Information Sharing Project', Huddle asks - where are we today? 

Optimising the Benefits of Hybrid IT
7 April 2021

SolarWinds explains how public sector organisations can make the most of their hybrid IT investments - delivering services that are both innovative and reliable