Civil service to pilot online recruitment tool to cut reliance on ‘outdated’ technology

Written by Rebecca Hill on 24 February 2017 in News

The government chief people officer Rupert McNeil has said that the civil service is using recruitment technology that is “40 or 50 years out of date” as the civil service announces plans to trial a cloud-based recruitment platform in efforts to tackle bias.

The civil service is one of 30 organisations piloting Applied in an effort to tackle bias in recruitment - Photo credit: PA

The recruitment tool, Applied, which was launched yesterday, has been developed by the social purpose company the Behavioural Insights Team, which was spun out of the Cabinet Office in 2014.

It aims to make recruitment fairer, and organisations more diverse, by cutting out a number of biases that can affect the application process and going beyond anonymising – or “blinding” – applications.

The cloud-based platform is now being used by 30 organisations, including Penguin, Cancer Research UK and Barnados, as well as the UK civil service.

Related content

Whitehall needs to ‘evolve’ its recruitment processes for digital staff
Government to replace Civil Service Jobs site

Speaking at the launch event, government chief people officer Rupert McNeil said that the civil service was “not getting the right people into the hopper” during recruitment and was relying on out-dated technology.

“[Recruitment] should be a huge, industrially rigorous process, but if you applied the test that you’d apply to a process like procurement and looked at how, in many cases, recruitment is done, it’s pretty awful from a wastage point of view,” he said.

“We’re making all sorts of errors in dropping people out of the process at the wrong stage, so we want [start making] the best decisions.”

He said that the civil service had been using technology used for recruitment was “maybe 40 or 50 years out of date” and not fit for purpose anymore. The technology behind the Applied platform offers a “fantastic” way of removing bias, McNeil said.

The platform requires applicants to fill in a series of questions that are based on work they might be expected to do in the role. These are anonymised and randomised, and recruiters will review a set of answers to just one question – a process known as “chunking” and similar to the way teachers mark exam questions.

The idea is to reduce “halo bias”, where a good or bad answer to one question colours a reviewer’s opinion of all the questions, regardless of their individual merits.

It also allows a number of reviewers to independently assess sets of questions and then compare their results afterwards, rather than in a group setting where people tend to be influenced by their peer’s opinions.

The government’s use of Applied is part of wider plans to move away from competency-based reviews, which McNeil said was “very rigid”.

He said: “[The competency-based approach] has been used more rigidly than it was intended to be used, and to the exclusion of other data that can be used to inform decision-making, and actually to the exclusion of good reasonable judgement by people who are hiring managers.”

McNeil added: “People can get very good at filling in the competency-based forms, but that doesn’t actually tell you a lot about their ability to do the job.”

Applied success

Applied’s chief executive office Kate Glazebrook said that the BIT tested the platform against the team’s standard recruitment approach of assessing CVs for a recent recruitment round, finding that they would have had to review three times as many CVs to identify the people who performed well at assessment.

Glazebrook added that anecdotal evidence from other users suggested that using Applied cut administration time by two-thirds, with a three times improvement in sourcing of diverse candidates.

The system also uses data gathered on applications to offer all applicants feedback, giving them their overall rankings for each question and information on their broad areas of strengths and weaknesses.

A panel discussion at the launch event identified potential future uses in ensuring that people were applying to the right jobs in the first place and taking the bias out of performance management and appraisals.

McNeil said that performance management was a place “where you get a lot of bias” and that it would “lend itself very much to this type of solution”.

However, McNeil stressed that, although there will be a lot of useful data generated, the new platform is not about automating the recruitment process, but about “making sure as much noise as possible is removed”.

Late last year, the Government Digital Service revealed plans to create a new recruitment platform for government that will replace Civil Service Jobs, which it said was not meeting user needs.

Share this page




Please login to post a comment or register for a free account.


Tim Hilton (not verified)

Submitted on 24 February, 2017 - 13:46
Recruitment technology that is 40 or 50 years out of date? Does anyone even stop to challenge this sort of mindless drivel? That would mean the Civil Service was using technology from between 1967 and 1977. Unless he's talking about pens and paper, I'm prepared to bet that remark simply doesn't stand up to any kind of close scrutiny.

Related Articles

Interview: London CDO Blackwell on why the capital must be ‘visionary, but pragmatic’
29 June 2018

Two weeks on from the publication of the strategy to make London the world’s smartest city, the capital’s chief digital officer Theo Blackwell talks PublicTechnology through the plan and...

Government major projects unit gets operations chief
16 August 2018

Infrastructure and Projects Authority – which helps departments ensure delivery of major technology programmes – appoints Alison Baptiste

Walsall Council offers £90k for newly created role as digital and transformation chief
6 August 2018

Assistant director-level post comes with remit to further the authority’s use of user-centred service design

Local government and the NHS do not want outsourced IT, studies find
2 August 2018

Research from Dods shows that most public sector workers are not in favour of bringing in commercial firms to provide their IT

Related Sponsored Articles

Intelligent Connectivity: Boosting Flexibility and Control
13 August 2018

At BT, we realise that digital technology is changing the way we all do business. Make smart decisions with intelligent connectivity.

BT: Intelligent Connectivity is where it all begins. Smarter decisions are the end result
7 August 2018

At BT, we realise that digital technology is changing the way we all do business. Make smart decisions with intelligent connectivity.

Building nation-level defences to fight cyber crime
30 July 2018

BT's Mark Hughes argues that nation states should act now to put in place cyber defences to protect themselves from the most advanced threats ever seen.

The inaugural Chamberlain Lecture at the iconic BT Tower
23 July 2018

On the 4th June 2018, BT partnered with Cratus Communications and Public Policy Projects for the inaugural Chamberlain Lecture given by Lord Heseltine at BT Tower.