Unwrapping government’s £300m Amazon package
Since a public sector-wide agreement with AWS was introduced six months ago, departments have signed contracts worth hundreds of millions with the cloud firm. PublicTechnology takes a closer look.
Credit: Jordan Kanouse from Pixabay - Image has been cropped, modified and added to
In 2013, the Cabinet Office introduced the ‘cloud first’ policy, which mandates that, during procurement processes, all central government entities must “fully evaluate” use of public cloud environments before looking at alternatives. Doing so is “strongly recommended” for the rest of the public sector.
In the eight years since, the public sector has had a variable relationship with cloud computing and, two years ago, it was even announced that cloud first was set to be replaced with “more appropriate guidance” as it had “become apparent that one size does not fit all”.
The long-standing policy was ultimately kept on and, bit by bit, the collective move away from on-site infrastructure has continued.
Perhaps not quite ‘cloud first’, but ‘cloud eventually’ now seems well within reach.
The One Government Cloud Strategy, put in place last year, aims to provide further fuel for adoption. The strategy, which followed discussions between officials and a range of vendors, aims to foster a more joined-up approach to cloud across government.
As part of the plan, the Crown Commercial Service has signed memoranda of understanding with some of the biggest providers of cloud hosting and software – IBM, Oracle, HPE, Google, Microsoft, and UKCloud – that will offer discounts and other benefits for all public-sector bodies by, effectively, treating them as a single customer.
The cloud crowd – Whitehall's AWS contracts since November
- Home Office – £120m
- HMRC – £94m
- DWP – £57m
- MoJ – £24m
- DVLA – £6.74m
- Companies House – £5m
- HM Land Registry – £4.5m
- FCDO – £2m
Last – but certainly not least – to sign an MoU was Amazon Web Services, which announced in November that it had agreed a three-year arrangement with CCS dubbed the One Government Value Agreement (OGVA).
In addition to the savings offered on the vendor’s services, AWS has also committed to providing cloud computing training to 6,000 civil servants via a “digital skills fund”.
Chris Hayman, the firm’s UK public sector director, says: “We are working with OGVA customers to build customised training programmes that are free of charge for staff and are designed to provide them with cloud expertise and skills including architecting in the cloud, developer and systems operations, security, big data and machine learning.”
In the meantime, those customers have been quick to start taking advantage of the cost savings provided by the agreement.
Since the introduction of the arrangement, AWS has been awarded new three-year contracts with the Home Office (£120m), the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (£2m), the Department for Work and Pensions (£57m), HM Revenue and Customs (£94m), HM Land Registry (£4.5m), the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency (£6.74m), the Ministry of Justice (£23.9m), and Companies House (£5m).
In many cases, these replaced incumbent arrangements with months or years left to run; HMRC’s deal superseded a contact signed with AWS as recently as September 2020 – two months before the OGVA was introduced.
The DWP was a launch partner of the public sector-wide commercial arrangement, entering into a new cloud-hosting contract with AWS on 1 December 2020. This replaced a deal that had been scheduled to run for another eight months.
“The contract is currently not delivering best value for money and DWP looked to find a replacement with improved discounts, which has been developed through Cabinet Office’s OGVA,” the contract-award notice says.
The DWP, and the other major departments to have renegotiated their AWS deals, form the second of two tiers of the agreement which, according to AWS, is designed to enable “larger organisations already using the cloud… [to] maximise benefits from their existing cloud environment, with participants benefiting from a new pricing structure”.
The first tier, meanwhile, offers training and guidance to help organisations “at the beginning of their cloud journey”.
Neither government nor AWS has put a figure on the level of discount available via the OGVA, but a CCS spokesperson told CSW that the improved terms would add up to tens of millions of pounds saved over the course of the deal’s lifetime.
“Many existing customers have retested their contracts to check value for money and ended up awarding contracts that include OGVA benefits,” they said. “CCS anticipates commercial benefits well in excess of £50m over the next three years.”
The procurement agency added that, in light of the arrangements put in place with AWS and six of its cloud rivals, similar public-sector wide agreements with major suppliers may follow.
“We do anticipate more MoUs in the future as they deliver commercial benefits to the public sector which would not otherwise have been possible to quantify or achieve,” the spokesperson said.
A stated aim of the OGVA is “helping more SMEs to take part in public-sector contracts”.
Given that the £300m-plus of deals listed above were all signed directly with AWS, it may not be immediately obvious how this will be achieved.
Hayman says that, over the last decade, more than 150 firms on the G-Cloud framework have “used AWS to help them deliver their own services – worth more £1.3bn – to the government”. More than half of these were SMEs, he adds.
What are the main objectives of the OGVA – and what would success look like?
The government has been operating a Public Cloud First policy since 2013, and the OGVA helps to accelerate the realisation of the benefits which were the goal behind this policy from the outset. The government has been clear that taking advantage of hyperscale cloud is helping transform how they operate, enabling them to build and run more resilient services, update them easily where we need to, and scale up quickly to meet peaks in demand. When the government contracts with AWS, it saves the taxpayer money, leads to better, more agile, more secure and more reliable public services and also enables a network of small and medium British technology companies to benefit from opportunities to sell to the government that they would not otherwise have had.
Chris Hayman, UK public sector director, AWS
Crown Commercial Service have negotiated a common MoU cloud procurement process with multiple companies and continue to roll this out to additional providers. This MoU aims to set out special terms and pricing for products and services which the provider will then make available to all public sector organisations. Companies signing an MoU should view the government as a single customer with multiple points of purchase and consumption, by offering the same discounts and benefits to all eligible customers. That is what success looks like.
“The OGVA is designed to be ‘channel neutral’, in that customers are able to access its benefits whether they contract directly with AWS or via one of the members of the AWS Partner Network, many of whom are SMEs,” Hayman says. “The choice of whether to contract directly with AWS, or via a partner is for our customers to make – experience suggests that when a customer chooses to contract for AWS services via a partner, it’s usually because the partner is bringing additional services or value that AWS doesn’t offer; for example, undertaking bespoke software development work.”
In addition to the potential implications for SMEs, another frequently aired concern about the rise of AWS is that – with so many of the biggest departments signing major, long-term deals with the company – government is becoming standardised on the vendor’s platform.
Asked about the implications of Amazon’s large and ever-growing footprint, CCS tells CSW that it remains committed to promoting choice for public-sector customers, with the spokesperson saying that “it’s important to note that there are a number of other cloud MoUs… all of [which were] an outcome of the One Government Cloud Strategy”.
“Contracting authorities have the power to decide who to contract with, and more than 5,000 suppliers were awarded places on G-Cloud 12, with 91% of them SMEs, offering a wide range of choice for potential customers,” they added. “MoUs standardise pricing for the whole public sector, making sure that customers can get the best deal for their procurement decisions.”
With £300m and counting having been spent in less than six months, it would seem that many in government are happy enough with the deal they are getting. And, when the time comes for others to relet their IT contracts, the cloud may – finally – be the first place they visit.
Report identifies continued prevalence of ageing tech as one of the major challenges facing the civil service’s digital ambitions
Tax agency’s programme to ‘deliver a step change’ in its use of tech begins in earnest
Minister says that, in light of the pandemic, department wishes to given businesses extra time to prepare
Julia Lopez, the minister responsible for GDS and CDDO, has moved departments – but the digital divisions may now receive more attention from the top of the Cabinet Office