Leaked letter from government’s national data guardian Fiona Caldicott says patient records were being used to test and develop Streams app – not for direct care
Implied consent was ‘not an appropriate legal basis’ for sharing patient records – Photo credit: Flickr, Sebastian Wiertz, CC BY 2.0
The legal basis that Google’s DeepMind and London’s Royal Free NHS Trust used to justify granting access to 1.6 million patient records was not appropriate, according to the UK’s national data guardian for health, Fiona Caldicott.
The healthcare arm of Google’s artificial intelligence company is working with the Royal Free to use patient data to develop an app, Streams, that will help doctors and nurses identify – and prioritise – patients at risk of acute kidney injury.
The project, launched in early 2016, came under fire when it was revealed that the data-sharing agreement gave the company access to a range of identifiable healthcare data on the 1.6 million patients passing through the hospitals each year.
Although the work was paused – later to be restated in November 2016 under a new agreement and a commitment from DeepMind to be more open with the public – the initial agreement is under investigation by the UK’s data watchdog, the Information Commissioner’s Office.
As part of this, the ICO asked Caldicott – who has written three reports into patient data sharing and consent within the health service – to give her opinion on the agreement.
Related content
Google’s DeepMind and NHS restart data-sharing deal with greater transparency
John Manzoni: Care.data was a ‘misstep’ that ‘put us back a long way’
Earning public trust in the age of cyber threats
This was reported to the ICO and the Royal Free in February, but was not made public until this week, when a letter to Stephen Powis, the medical director of the Royal Free Hospital in London, was leaked to Sky News.
In it, Caldicott noted that the company and trust had said that the basis for sharing the data was implied consent, because it was for the purposes direct care.
But, she said, the data was being used to test and develop the Streams app, and could not be regarded as direct care, meaning it wasn’t appropriate to use the legal basis of implied consent.
“It is my view, and that of my panel that the purpose for the transfer of 1.6 million identifiable patient records were only used for the testing of Streams application, and not for the provision of direct care to patients,” she said.
Caldicott added that she “did not believe that when the patient data was shared with Google DeepMind, implied consent for direct care was an appropriate legal basis”, and that it was her “considered opinion” that patients would not have reasonably expected their records to be used in this way.
“My view is that when work is taking place to develop new technology this cannot be regarded as direct care, even if the intended end result when the technology is deployed is to provide direct care,” the letter stated.
“Implied consent is only an appropriate legal basis for the disclosure of identifiable data for the purposes of direct case if it aligns with people’s reasonable expectations.”
Elsewhere in her letter, Caldicott stresses that both she and her panel “keenly appreciate the great benefits that new technologies such as Streams can offer to patients, in terms of better, safer, more timely care”.
And, although the letter does not raise any issues with the way the app – which has been in full use since January this year – is currently working, it said that the full benefits of innovative technologies will not be realised unless unless the use of patient data is done in “a transparent and secure manner, which helps to build public trust”.
Royal Free: ‘NHS remained in full control of patient data’
In a statement sent to PublicTechnology, a spokesperson for the Royal Free said that the partners took a “safety-first approach”, by testing Streams with real patient data to make sure it presented the information accurately before using it in a live setting.
“Real patient data is routinely used in the NHS to check new systems are working properly before turning them fully live,” the spokesperson said. “No responsible hospital would ever deploy a system that hadn’t been thoroughly tested. The NHS remained in full control of all patient data throughout.”
However, they added the hospital took Caldicott’s decision “seriously”, and acknowledged that, as the project was “one of the first of its kind in the NHS”, there were “always lessons we can learn”.
This point was also picked up on by Caldicott in her letter, which said that further guidance for organisations developing new technologies “would be useful” and that the Department of Health was “looking closely at the regulatory framework and guidance” it provides on this.
The letter was also sent to the ICO, to feed into its investigation, which the organisation said in a statement was nearly finished.
“Our investigation into the sharing of patient information between the Royal Free NHS Trust and Deep Mind is close to conclusion,” the statement said.
“We continue to work with the National Data Guardian and have been in regular contact with the Royal Free and Deep Mind who have provided information about the development of the Streams app. This has been subject to detailed review as part of our investigation. It’s the responsibility of businesses and organisations to comply with data protection law.”
The product you present demonstrates genuine innovation and creative thinking. It is evident that time and effort have been invested at every stage of its development to ensure it meets the highest expectations.
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: Mexican Easy Pharm – medicine in mexico pharmacies
mexican mail order pharmacies https://mexicaneasypharm.com/# Mexican Easy Pharm
mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs https://mexicaneasypharm.com/# buying from online mexican pharmacy
buying from online mexican pharmacy
https://cytpharm.com/# Cyt Pharm
prednisone 10mg
http://predpharm.com/# Pred Pharm
buy cheap prednisone
http://kamapharm.com/# Kama Pharm
20mg prednisone
https://semapharm24.shop/# generic rybelsus tabs
30mg prednisone
https://dappharm.shop/# DapPharm
can you buy prednisone over the counter
http://semapharm24.com/# rybelsus semaglutide tablets
canine prednisone 5mg no prescription
https://dappharm.com/# cheap priligy
prednisone pill 20 mg
https://dappharm.shop/# buy dapoxetine online
prednisone online australia
https://semapharm24.com/# semaglutide tablets price
generic prednisone online
https://cytpharm.com/# buy cytotec online
how much is prednisone 10 mg
http://predpharm.com/# PredPharm
prednisone 10 mg tablets
https://predpharm.com/# Pred Pharm
prednisone coupon
https://kamapharm.shop/# Kama Pharm
online order prednisone
http://kamapharm.com/# Kama Pharm
prednisone 50 mg tablet canada
https://farmabrufen.shop/# BRUFEN 600 acquisto online
farmaci senza ricetta elenco
https://farmasilditaly.com/# siti sicuri per comprare viagra online
farmacia online piГ№ conveniente
https://farmabrufen.com/# BRUFEN prezzo
Farmacie on line spedizione gratuita
https://farmatadalitaly.com/# acquisto farmaci con ricetta
top farmacia online
https://farmabrufen.com/# Farma Brufen
migliori farmacie online 2024
Farmacie on line spedizione gratuita BRUFEN prezzo Farmacia online miglior prezzo
Casinos often host special holiday promotions. https://winchile.pro/# Hay casinos en Santiago y ViГ±a del Mar.
Los torneos de poker generan gran interГ©s.: jugabet casino – jugabet.xyz
Some casinos have luxurious spa facilities.: taya365 com login – taya365 login
taya365 com login taya365 login Most casinos offer convenient transportation options.
The casino experience is memorable and unique. http://taya777.icu/# Security measures ensure a safe environment.
Las promociones atraen nuevos jugadores diariamente.: winchile – winchile.pro
Las promociones atraen nuevos jugadores diariamente.: jugabet chile – jugabet
Players can enjoy high-stakes betting options. http://winchile.pro/# Las mГЎquinas tienen diferentes niveles de apuesta.
Many casinos provide shuttle services for guests.: phtaya.tech – phtaya casino
Live music events often accompany gaming nights.: taya365.art – taya365
phtaya phtaya casino Responsible gaming initiatives are promoted actively.
The Philippines has several world-class integrated resorts. http://winchile.pro/# Los juegos de mesa son clГЎsicos eternos.
Los casinos organizan eventos especiales regularmente.: win chile – winchile
The ambiance is designed to excite players.: phtaya.tech – phtaya casino
Security measures ensure a safe environment. http://taya777.icu/# Manila is home to many large casinos.
phmacao club phmacao.life Casinos often host special holiday promotions.
Las aplicaciones mГіviles permiten jugar en cualquier lugar.: jugabet chile – jugabet casino
Slot machines feature various exciting themes.: taya777 login – taya777.icu
Players must be at least 21 years old. http://phtaya.tech/# Players can enjoy high-stakes betting options.
The casino scene is constantly evolving.: taya777 – taya777 register login
phmacao com login phmacao com login Some casinos feature themed gaming areas.
Gaming regulations are overseen by PAGCOR. http://phtaya.tech/# Gambling can be a social activity here.
Las tragamonedas ofrecen grandes premios.: winchile.pro – winchile.pro
п»їCasinos in the Philippines are highly popular. http://phmacao.life/# The casino scene is constantly evolving.
Security measures ensure a safe environment.: taya777 login – taya777 register login
The thrill of winning keeps players engaged.: taya365.art – taya365 login
taya777 app taya777 register login Casino visits are a popular tourist attraction.
Poker rooms host exciting tournaments regularly. https://taya777.icu/# Players can enjoy high-stakes betting options.
Players can enjoy high-stakes betting options.: taya365 – taya365 login
High rollers receive exclusive treatment and bonuses.: phmacao club – phmacao com login
phmacao phmacao club Many casinos offer luxurious amenities and services.
Gambling regulations are strictly enforced in casinos.: phmacao – phmacao casino
La seguridad es prioridad en los casinos.: jugabet casino – jugabet
https://phmacao.life/# Slot machines attract players with big jackpots.
Slot machines attract players with big jackpots.
winchile winchile casino La mГєsica acompaГ±a la experiencia de juego.
The poker community is very active here.: phmacao club – phmacao com login
Gambling regulations are strictly enforced in casinos.: taya365.art – taya365
https://phtaya.tech/# Gaming regulations are overseen by PAGCOR.
The casino scene is constantly evolving.
Entertainment shows are common in casinos.: taya365 – taya365 login
taya777 login taya777 app The ambiance is designed to excite players.
Some casinos feature themed gaming areas.: phtaya – phtaya login
The casino scene is constantly evolving. https://taya365.art/# Manila is home to many large casinos.
taya777 taya777 app Cashless gaming options are becoming popular.
Live music events often accompany gaming nights.: taya777.icu – taya777 app
Slot tournaments create friendly competitions among players. https://phtaya.tech/# Promotions are advertised through social media channels.
Hay casinos en Santiago y ViГ±a del Mar.: winchile – win chile
winchile casino winchile.pro La diversiГіn nunca se detiene en los casinos.
Resorts provide both gaming and relaxation options.: taya365 login – taya365 login
Casinos offer delicious dining options on-site.: phtaya casino – phtaya casino
buying prescription drugs in mexico online: xxl mexican pharm – xxl mexican pharm
Cheapest online pharmacy: family pharmacy – Cheapest online pharmacy
family pharmacy online pharmacy delivery usa Online pharmacy USA
no prescription required pharmacy https://megaindiapharm.com/# Mega India Pharm
online pharmacy delivery usa: Cheapest online pharmacy – family pharmacy